7 BEST EYELINERS.. 7. e.l.f. Waterproof Eyeliner Pen ($1, eyeslipsface.com)..Cheap, yes, but it's a pretty good liner for $1..It can be messy if you are not used to applying eyeliner on a regular basis and the staying power, well for me, is pretty good..I can be tough to apply and blend though

These are so good you can get through all of This Is Us looking fresh as a daisy.